Total recall for Nokia?
By Peg Monahan, BuyerZone.com Content Manager
April 24, 2001
A software glitch in three of Nokia's top-selling phone models could render one of every
10 cell phones in the United States useless when Sprint PCS and Verizon Wireless begin
to upgrade mobile networks this year. The handsets in Nokia's 2100, 5100, and 6100 series
(more than 21 models total, sold in the U.S. and Canada since 1997) will not be able to
connect to the higher speed networks unless Nokia either recalls and reprograms the phones
or collaborates with wireless network carriers to modify the technology underlying the
migration from second generation (2G) to third generation (3G) networks.
Both Sprint and Verizon plan to deploy 3G networks in phases, beginning in October and
ending by 2004. The new 3G technology enhances carriers' ability to conduct voice and data,
significantly increasing transmission speed while simultaneously decreasing handset battery
consumption. This will enable you to use your mobile phone for much more than simply reading
e-mail: You will be able to surf the Web or watch video clips at broadband speeds, dial
directly into your company's intranet, or access software applications to perform functions
such as downloading slides for a presentation.
Subscribers interested in these services must buy new handsets. But the issue is whether
subscribers who don't want the new applications can continue using their current handsets
to connect to 3G networks for voice calls and data transfer at lower speeds. For owners
of Nokia 2100, 5100, and 6100 phones, the answer is "no." As of October, when the first
phase of the migration to 3G networks is scheduled to be completed, these handsets will
not be able to link to wireless networks at all.
Why is Nokia, the world's largest wireless phone manufacturer, in such a bind? The answer
lies in how Nokia translated research data on the Code Division Multiple Access (CDMA)
standard, a common 2G network. Had the company followed 2G CDMA specifications when developing
2G phones, these older phones would be able to access the new 3G networks for analog voice
service, at the very least.
What does all this mean for you if you own a Nokia series 2100, 5100, or 6100 phone,
or were planning on purchasing one this year (The newest generation of Nokia phones, due
to ship in 2002, does not contain the glitch)? Because recalling millions of phones would
be nearly impossible, Nokia prefers to resolve the problem by placing a software patch
in the 3G network infrastructure. Nokia is working with wireless network systems manufacturers,
including Lucent, to develop such a patch to be loaded into base stations, allowing the
older phones to tap into the 3G networks.
While a software patch would benefit Nokia most, and Sprint and Verizon are committed
to finding a solution, experts agree it will take 30 to 45 days to determine whether to
resolve the issue with a software fix to wireless base stations or a handset chip replacement.
And, whichever alternative is deemed best, the technology must be developed and carefully
tested before it is implemented.
The wisest course of action for now is to wait and watch: Between the large number of
cell phones affected and the imminent rollout of 3G networks, a sound, inexpensive, and
quickly implemented solution is in everyone's best interest.
To read more about how cell phones might affect your health, check out Cell
phone recall renews concerns about health.